Understanding Trading Penalties

Regulatory Penalties for Non-Compliance:

Regulators impose penalties for non-compliance with trading regulations. Below is an overview of common penalties and the scenarios in which they apply:

1. Margin Shortfall Penalty:

  • Cause: Insufficient margin for F&O positions or equity trades.

  • Penalties:

    • < Rs 1 lakh or < 10% of margin: 0.50%
    • = > Rs 1 lakh or >= 10% of margin: 1.00%
  • Repeated Shortfalls:

    • More than 3 consecutive days: 5% penalty per instance.
    • More than 5 instances in a month: 5% penalty per instance.
    • MCX Specific: After 3 shortfalls in a month, a 5% penalty is applied from the 4th instance onwards.
  • GST:18% on the penalty amount.

  • Reporting:
    Penalties are posted on T+6 day.

2. Trade Code Modifications:

  • Cause: Modifications in client codes.

  • Penalties:

    • < 5% modifications: 1% of trade value.
    • = 5% modifications: 2% of trade value.

3. Auction Penalties:

  • Cause: Short delivery when selling shares not present in your Demat Account.

  • Scenarios:

    • BTST (Buy Today Sell Tomorrow): Occurs when the shares bought the previous day are not delivered.
    • Selling with NRML Margin: Failing to buy back the shares before market close.
  • Penalties:

    • T+1 Day: 150% of the sale value is blocked, and a provisional debit of 150% of the sale value is applied.
    • T+2 Day: Actual auction obligation is debited, and a 1% auction penalty is applied.
  • Auction Obligation Calculation:
    The lowest auction price within a 20% range of the T+1 closing price is used for calculation.

Note: Exercise due diligence in trading to avoid these penalties. For detailed scenarios and rates, refer to NSE and MCX resources.


Was this article helpful?

That’s Great!

Thank you for your feedback

Sorry! We couldn't be helpful

Thank you for your feedback

Let us know how can we improve this article!

Select at least one of the reasons
CAPTCHA verification is required.

Feedback sent

We appreciate your effort and will try to fix the article

Still need help?

Create Ticket